"If you don't like it, just quit. Studying is a luxury." Those were the words that celebrity educator and television personality Osamu Hayashi chose to open his salvo against unmotivated students in Japan that is now drawing a round of applause from Japanese internet commentators.

Osamu Hayashi is perhaps Japan's most famous juku (cram school) lecturer, having taken on a role of respected television personality to be consulted on matters of education, and gaining popularity via commercial appearances backed by his catchphrase "Ima desho!" ("It's now or never!")

Perhaps it is his experience as a prominent figure in Japan's cram school system that allowed him to so harshly voice frustration with unmotivated students who lack the discipline to study. On the April 3rd broadcast of "Hayashi-sensei ga odoroku hatsumimi-gaku" (林先生が驚く初耳学), or "Professor Hayashi's School of Surprising Second Hand Knowledge", Hayashi was asked "What do you do to raise the motivation of students?" Hayashi was blunt in responding, calling upon the words of a university seminar lecturer who inspired him:

'If you don't like it, just quit. Studying is a luxury.' "All over the world, you have kids who are dying for a chance to study. They are poor, so they have to take action. Their parents not only look after them and send them to school, but the kids are so blessed that parents pay expensive tuition for them. And even with all that, they still aren't motivated. There is no meaning in studying for people who don't realize just how blessed they are. If that's the case, just quit!"

The message seems to be that academic learning is wasted upon students who cannot be appreciative of an opportunity to better themselves, both for individual gain and support of their families. While very harsh, it has resonated with thousands of Japanese people, with many re-tweeting screen-captures saying:

"Sound argument!"

"There are so many people I want to show these comments to..."

"It's absolutely as he says. But when you're a kid you don't get that, and later regret it and say "why didn't I study more?!" That's why adults tell kids to study."

Even if you're unmotivated, studying is something you just do.

Of course, it's not a message that agrees with everyone. The loudest argument of opposition being summed up in this tweet below, that reads: "That's wrong. It's not "we're paying for it so do it", a society that labels people who don't study well as useless is at fault. People who don't do well in school should be encouraged with other hobbies, as just forcing them to study is pointless and they won't be a service to society."

It's a counterpoint not without its support, either. Just last February famous educator and best-selling author Hirotada Ototake ripped the drone-like training of the Japanese education system, calling Japanese schools "factories for salarymen" that would have stifled the creative entrepreneurship of Bill Gates and Steve Jobs. The lack of variety of learning methods and approaches he critiqued Japanese schools for, is perhaps tied to the cram school system that Hayashi finds himself trying to rid of unmotivated students.


Source: YouTube

At first glance, Hayashi's point is harsh but truthful (although as someone pitching cram schools as a business model, what else would he say?), and there is still plenty of merit in them. A student who can't apply himself or herself in class despite not really wanting to be there (as well as their parents' care and financial backing), and lazily treats school as a cruel Herculean labor is unlikely to be rewarded by the academic system.

Perhaps, however, that system is only offering salvation for one type of student. Students flush with artistic and creative depth may not successfully make it through a system that relies on parroting teachers and not engaging themselves in different methods of learning to search out their true talent and potential.

While there is certainly no shame in applying oneself to working towards a career path strictly through the rigors of academics, you eventually have to wonder just how many truthfully unmotivated delinquents created the sentiment of "if you aren't motivated, quit", and how many potential leaders and visionaries lost their motivation because of it.

By - grape Japan editorial staff.